Fear for Free

Take that elf down from the shelf, friends, Christmas is over. I don’t have one of the little guys so I have to mark the end of the Season of Using a Naughty Overpriced Plastic Doll to Scare Kids into Behaving in a different way. Mainly by daily threatenings to return all gifts to Santa. (But since 2/3 of my children are no longer believers and 1/3 has a bad case of selective hearing, my threats are nothing more than idle if even heard).

Here’s a question for you Elfers out there though:

How does a naughty elf encourage good behavior?

I mean, I get that it’s fun to have him/her do silly things every night (actually this a lie because the thought of having to remember to do one more thing EVERY NIGHT in the month of December and then to have to make that one more thing a creative one, STRESSES. ME. OUT.), but how does that translate into outright fear of misbehavior?

Take for instance, this picture:

Shelf Elf
really, Pinterest?

Every morning this is the conversation I have with my children, “WILL YOU PLEASE PUT THE CAP BACK ON THE TOOTHPASTE SO IT DOESN’T GET ALL OVER THE COUNTER?? AND SQUEEZE FROM THE BOTTOM. SQUEEZE. FROM. THE. BOTTOM!!” How could this possibly help lower the toothpaste covered counter incidents in my home?  My heart is pounding just looking at this picture because, really, I don’t have enough kid-created messes to clean up, I’m going to make some of my own? Do you know when this would be cleaned up at my house? June. Maybe. If my ultimate goal is to scare my kids into never misusing toothpaste again, how could this possibly help?
Or here’s another Pinterest suggestion:
Funny & Creative Elf on the Shelf Ideas - much needed!!!
Have your elf steal from you. Because it’s not enough you paid $30 (if you got a deal)  for this creep, now he’s going to take your cash, charge up your credit card, AND teach your kids it’s okay. This is the guy Santa’s sent to keep an eye on them, right? So either Santa’s been snookered just like everyone else who’s bought into Elfie/Mr. Jingles/Harvey (or whatever pseudonym he’s using at your house) or Santa’s standard have seriously slipped.
Or how about this:
Cute website for elf ideas.
You want to know what my kids’ reaction to this would be? Not, “Mommy, mommy look how funny Elfie is!” or “Can I drink syrup through a straw too?” No, their reaction would be “Straws as a syrup delivery device? Why did I never think of this before? Who needs pancakes or waffles? Let’s cut out the middle man! Girl 2, you get the straws. Girl 3, you watch for Mom while Girl 2 and I drink our breakfast. If there’s any left, you can have some too.”
Call me dense or clueless or the meanest mom ever, but I just don’t get it. I mean, I’m not against fear. I’m pro-fear. Kids should be scared into being good. But how does a mirror defacing, purse invading, syrup sucking doll accomplish this? Especially when he’s kept in a box for eleven months out of the year.
Here’s how it’s always worked at my house (and the house I grew up in). The kids have a week after Christmas to get all their fighting and naughtiness out without too much retribution. Hopefully they’re distracted enough by all their new crap that things don’t get too out of control. But starting January 1st, Santa’s elves start watching again. But only Mom can see them. They’re always peeking in windows somewhere. And they’re are windows everywhere. Go ahead, think of somewhere without windows (okay, outside, but the elves are already out there). Dungeons, right? And let’s see a kid misbehave in one of those.
The elves are always watching. ALWAYS. And there’s more than one of them.
Fear can be free, my friends. Free. All you have to do when naughtiness is about to erupt is calmly say, “Oh, I think I just saw an elf peeking in the window.” Stops them in their tracks. Now the focus has gone from being bad to being outright scared of something they can’t see but can see them. Fear of the unknown, people, is the greatest fear of all.
Follow your statement by quietly signing a few of the creepier lines from Santa Claus is Coming to Town. “He knows when you are sleeping. He knows when you’re awake. He knows if you’ve been bad or good. SO BE GOOD FOR GOODNESS SAKE!”
Boom. Elves go from rosy cheeked pranksters to a cross between Edward Cullen and Chucky.
Happy New Year and You’re Welcome. 
WARNING! This method may not actually induce good behavior. Side effects include nightmares, fear of dark hallways, fear of being alone, fear of windows, desire for window coverings, and fear.

6 thoughts on “Fear for Free

  1. DMS says:

    This post is hilarious! I do not have children, but I have tons of friends who have the elf at their house and they have to think of something to do with him every night. It sounds exhausting! Plus, he is always causing mischief and messing things up. I like the idea of the elves that are everywhere that only moms/grownups can see. Brilliant! ~Jess


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s